PDF《Guidelines》

49 228 885-1 ? Fax: +

49 228 885-2777 ? [email protected] ? www.dfg.de DFG DFG form 1.307 C 12/15 page

3 of

5 1 Research Criteria 1.1 Participating researchers and institutions ? Academic qualification and supervisory experience of the participating researchers ? Group composition and internal collaboration ? Quality and suitability of the host institutions and existing equipment 1.2 Research programme ? Quality and originality of the research programme ? Disciplinary and/or interdisciplinary value added ? Appropriateness and coherence with respect to the objectives of a Research Training Group ? Integration into the research profile of the location

2 Training Criteria 2.1 Supervision and training strategy ? Recruiting and supervision strategy ? Training and interaction within the Research Training Group ? Doctoral record of the Research Training Group and achievements of its doctoral re- searchers ? Organisation 2.2 University integration and collaboration ? Integration into general doctoral training programmes, if available ? Integration into the university's academic structure and early-career support ? Value added by collaboration with other institutions (in terms of doctoral training) Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft Kennedyallee

40 ?

53175 Bonn ? Postal address:

53170 Bonn Phone: +

49 228 885-1 ? Fax: +

49 228 885-2777 ? [email protected] ? www.dfg.de DFG DFG form 1.307 C 12/15 page

4 of

5 III Additional Aspects of the Review

1 Confidentiality All proposals submitted to the DFG, the correspondence with reviewers, the reviews and the identity of the reviewers and participating review board members must be treated con- fidentially. The scientific content of a proposal you review may not be exploited for your own and/or others' scientific purposes.

2 Obligation to Follow Rules of Good Scientific Practice1 The rules of good scientific practice also apply to reviewers. A violation of these rules can result in a charge of scientific misconduct. In particular, any infringement against the princi- ple of confidentiality as per III.1. is considered scientific misconduct.

3 Conflicts of Interest The DFG Head Office is not able to investigate all circumstances that could be interpreted as a conflict of interest. The DFG therefore relies on your assistance to determine whether your participation in the review meeting would be appropriate and to enable us to contact another reviewer early on if necessary. Should circumstances exist that may be interpreted as conflict of interest, please inform the responsible DFG staff before participating in a review meeting. If you participate in a DFG meeting without first having contacted the DFG regarding a possible conflict of interest, the DFG Head Office will assume that, to the best of your knowledge, no apparent conflict of interest exists. If you realise during or after a meeting that there may be or may have been an apparent conflict of interest, you should also contact the DFG Head Office immediately.

1 The rules of good scientific practice are presented in detail in the white paper entitled "Safeguarding Good Scien- tific Practice" and in the usage guidelines for Research Training Groups (DFG form 2.22). Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft Kennedyallee

40 ?

53175 Bonn ? Postal address:

53170 Bonn Phone: +

49 228 885-1 ? Fax: +

49 228 885-2777 ? [email protected] ? www.dfg.de DFG DFG form 1.307 C 12/15 page

5 of

5 The DFG guidelines on avoiding conflicts of interest (DFG form 10.201) can be found on the DFG website. www.dfg.de/formulare/10_201